Avoid Knife Collection Scams: What to Watch Out For When Collecting Pocket Knives

Love pocket knife collecting? I completely get it. Who isn’t fascinated by the intricate craftsmanship and usefulness of a good tactical blade or gentleman’s folder? But here’s the thing – the surge of interest in folding knives also attracts scammers hoping to take advantage of collectors. 

infographic poster aa

Believe me, I’ve heard stories from folks who were tricked by slick counterfeits passed off as rare antique knives. Or found themselves caught up in bidding wars, only to later realize the “collector” they were bidding against was a fraud. Don’t let yourself be a victim.

The world of knife collecting is awesome, but you gotta have your eyes wide open. I’ve seen a lot in my time and my goal with this article is to give you a heads up on common collection scams to watch for, red flags that say “run away!”, and tips to grow your collection safely. I wanna make sure your budget goes toward scoring that perfect Buck knife or Spyderco blade – not lining a scammer’s pockets. So let’s begin.

II. Learn the Risks

While growing an impressive knife collection is exciting,  hobbyists should be aware of shady practices that can occur including:

intense bidding war 99
  • Counterfeits – This is one of the biggest problems currently out there. Dishonest sellers deceive uninformed buyers by passing off fake knives using false documentation.
  • Auction manipulation – Another problem is false bidding wars that are fabricated just to drive up prices, with the scam artist disappearing after the buyer thinks they have won.
  • Non-delivery – You’ll also need to watch out for con artists going after your hard-earned money for knives that never materialize into actual products.
  • Obscurity – Finally, sellers failing to disclose damages or issues. 
  • Non-delivery – You’ll also need to watch out for con artists going after your hard-earned money for knives that never materialize into actual products.
  • Obscurity – Finally, sellers failing to disclose damages or issues. 

However, hobbyists can largely avoid pitfalls through prudent research and some skepticism. 

III. Red Flags Collectors Need to Watch For

Growing your knife collection takes time. While most sellers out there are good people, you need to be on the lookout for things that don’t seem just right. Below are some red flags to watch out for as you look for knives:

portrait of a man inspecting a pocketknife d7
  • Ridiculously low prices – We all love a good deal. But offers that seem too good to be true probably are. Use your judgment.
  • No seller history – Sellers with little feedback or presence should set off alarms. Although they very well can be legit, it’s tough to trust someone with no reputation.
  • Unusual answers – If a seller seems evasive about revealing details on materials, manufacturing dates, past owners, etc. simply walk away.
  • Pressure tactics – This one is pretty obvious, but anyone demanding fast payment outside of the normal policy screams scam.
  • Unusual payment requests – Honest sellers will happily accept secure payment methods, but red flag the deal if the seller insists on sketchy options.
  • Bad vibes – Always trust your gut! If a knife listing seems off for ANY reasons even if can’t quite articulate why, move on. Odds are you will be glad that you did!

The bottom line is to always be on high alert, but don’t get paranoid. Use common sense, ask questions, and only buy from reputable sellers to grow your antique Bowie or Swiss Benchmade collection safely.

IV. Tips for Safe Transactions

Luckily, there are some easy ways to avoid falling victim to scams as you score knives for your collection:

  • Use well-known auction sites – Platforms like eBay offer buyer protection so you can shop with more confidence.
  • Check seller ratings – Buying from an experienced eBay seller with positive feedback means fewer risks.
  • Ask for more pics – If a seller only posts a single photo or the image is fuzzy don’t be afraid to ask for more.
  • Confirm details – Any good seller would know the knife’s history, materials used, the year it was made, etc.
  • Use secure payment options – No legit knife seller will hesitate to use standard payment methods like PayPal or Stripe, just to name a few.
  • When in doubt, bow out! – If anything leaves you with hesitating, just skip to the next listing. There are plenty more knives to choose from!
modest display case 9f

So as you can see, you can grow an awesome Bowie, Buck, or Victorinox collection without getting caught up in funny business dealings. It just takes some wisdom and putting safety first. 

Now speaking of safety…let’s go over some questions that you should be asking to make sure that you don’t regret your deal later.

V. Questions to Ask Sellers 

So, you’ve got a promising lead on that antique Case knife or limited edition Benchmade Griptilian. But, before pulling out your wallet, here are some questions that you probably should ask.

  • What’s the full ownership history? – Reputable sellers will know details like the original manufacturing date, past owners, and at least some of the acquisition trail.
  • Any issues you’re aware of? – Listen for hesitance or vagueness around known damages, repairs needed, and functionality problems.
  • Why are you selling? – If the response is that the seller needs the money or they found something better, take notice.
business transaction 1a
  • Would you mind more pics? – Again, decent sellers will happily provide detailed visuals without resistance.
  • Do you have documentation? – Serial numbers, receipts, and certificates always add confidence to any deal.

Basically, if a seller seems sketchy in any way or refuses more pictures, walk away! Clear communication establishes trust in any deal.

VI. Case Studies: Scams to Learn From

Now let’s take a look at a real world example.

knife shop b4

It just goes to show you, when you think you’ve found an unbelievable deal and you just can’t wait to put up your hard earned cash, take a breath and do your homework. Make sure everything checks out before moving forward. Use Joe’s close call as inspiration and hopefully, you’ll never fall victim to these kinds of scams!

VII. Protecting Yourself from Online Scams

As you can see by now, buying knives comes with risks. And this could not be more prevalent when it comes to dealing with the internet. So here are some additional ideas on how to be smart when shopping on the web.

online scams 9d
  • Guard personal information – Keep payment info, your location, and your full name private until you’re convinced that the sale is legit.
  • Research unfamiliar sites – Search online reviews before providing data to random storefronts.
  • Beware of pressure sellers – Real businesses won’t pressure you to buy, enter contests, or click links without giving you a chance to think. 
  • Check shipping – Ensure any site that you are dealing with has transparent policies on fulfillment time, packaging, and delivery before purchasing.
  • Track payments – Sticking with secure apps allows purchase reversal if the items differ from the descriptions.

The web makes snagging that rare Italian switchblade or Opinel folding knife easy, but it also gives scammers an easy way to get your money. As long as you’re vigilant in protecting personal data, and taking a close look at who you are dealing with you should be fine. Up next. let’s take a closer look at some common scams.

VIII. Common Scams 

As awesome as a hobby is, there are always a few bad apples that spoil the bunch. Here are some common ways dishonest sellers target buyers:

Counterfeit knives – Scammers pawn off cheap knockoffs as coveted brands. They count on hobbyists, especially those new to the hobby on not noticing crappy fit, dull edges, and other red flags. They buy cheaply made knives and then resell them to unsuspecting buyers as custom, expensive knives.

Fake Damascus – Real decorative Damascus steel has intricate visible layers. Fakes might have fake etched surface patterns instead. Scrutinize sellers’ photos before paying.

No seller history – Check for ratings, reviews, and feedback history. Never buy pricey knives from sellers with a zero reputation trail.

Unusual payment demands –
Legit sellers happily accept secure payment apps with purchase protection. Red flag if they only take Zelle or crypto!

The huge thrill of scoring an incredible deal can be blinding. But, like I’ve said several times before “if it seems too good to be true – it almost always is!” Save your money for trustworthy sellers instead.

IX. Tips for New Collectors 

new knife collectors b8

Just beginning to build a sweet knife collection? Welcome! But don’t jump in blindly or your inexperience may cost you. First, spend time getting to know what styles and brands spark your interest before spending money.

Start small with common knives to understand manufacturing and materials. Select local dealers you can meet face to face over random eBay sellers. And never feel rushed when examining a blade, no matter how pushy the sales guy is. Real enthusiasts won’t mind!

Once you get a feel for common brand names, steels, handle types, etc. you can start gradually expanding into rarer custom pieces. But pace yourself building your collection rather than purchasing expensive showpieces just to impress. Your journey into old traditional or new modern knives should be fun – don’t ignore red flags in the hunt for prestigious or cool knives.

X. Tips for The Experienced Knife Collector

So you’ve been collecting pocket knives for a while and own some gorgeous custom Buck Damascus steel beauties. Don’t let your experience make you overconfident! Still, apply common sense to protect that prized accumulation.

experienced knife collectors 1c

Sure, you recognize quality handle fittings, blade lines, and provenance details. But occasional verification still helps; get second opinions on authenticity or appraisals, especially for high-dollar acquisitions.

And just because a seller boasts an impressive reputation for having antique switchblades, doesn’t mean they still might not have the occasional lapse in integrity. Remember beloved community members have been known to fall from grace over gambling debts or messy divorces.

Stay vigilant by documenting all transactions, communications, and details to cover yourself if a disagreement should occur. No matter how advanced your collecting skills, regular authentication, and careful records will keep your collection safe.


Entering the world of pocket knife collecting is an incredibly rewarding hobby. But as we’ve covered, one must educate themselves on risks from unscrupulous sellers and scam tactics that can quickly drain wallets while damaging trust in the community. 

pocket knife collection fb

Understanding and identifying tactics like bait pricing, counterfeit blades, false bidding, and verifying seller reputation is essential. While most enthusiasts are ethical, exceptions exist of those more interested in exploiting hobbyists for cash than appreciating a good tactical blade.

Remember that if something seems too good to be true it likely is. Newcomers should start small, learn manufacturing details, compare examples in person whenever possible, question sketchy sellers, and authenticate expensive acquisitions. Saving a few dollars isn’t worth obtaining a counterfeit knife. 

Collect patiently, not impulsively. Though scams persist, remaining focused on adding quality over quantity pieces will give you the best chance of avoiding deception while enjoying this creative and inspiring hobby. 

Here at Kwaks Trading Post, we have heard many stories regarding the hobby. We have also enjoyed 40 years of buying and selling knives. That’s why from our experiences we thought you would appreciate this article so that you could enjoy the hobby and continue to grow your collection. It’s only by standing together that the hobby of knife collecting will grow for many years to come. 

Thank you for reading and we hope you enjoyed the article. Let us know if you have any questions. We would also like to remind you that we are very interested in buying as well as selling knives.

Finally, don’t forget to hit the share button so your friends can benefit from this post as well!

Frequently Asked Questions

What questions should I ask a seller before purchasing a knife?

Ask about materials, manufacturing date, past owners, reason for selling, and if online, request lots of detailed photos. Gauge if their responses seem hesitant or vague.

What should I watch out for when bidding on knives in online auctions?

Watch for shill bidding where the seller bids against you to drive up the price or fake bids from phantom accounts. Make sure real people are actually bidding.

I found a knife I want for way cheaper than normal. Is it too good to be true?

Most likely – unbelievable deals often turn out to be counterfeit knives or bait pricing scams. Do your research before buying.

Latest Posts

44th Edition Blue Book of Gun Values

The 44th Edition Blue Book of Gun Values is all new and updated for 2023

Check Current Price

Disclosure: We earn commissions from Amazon affiliate links at no extra cost to you.

select from the list below for additional posts